Recorded: 21 Sep 2025
Edited: 02 Oct 2025
Released: 03 Oct 2025

Links:
The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald - Wikipedia
Gordon Lightfoot - Wreck Of The Edmund Fitzgerald (Official Audio)
The Great Lakes Triangle (1980 NOAA Teacher’s Guide, rev. 1982, pdf)
What is a seiche?
Lake Michigan Triangle - Wikipedia
Skeptoid Podcast #464: The Lake Michigan Triangle
The UnBelievable: Lake Michigan Triangle's Mysterious Phenomena (Season 1)
Navigating the Mysteries of the Lake Michigan Triangle - Discovery UK
Great Lakes Lore #18: The Lake Ontario Triangle
Ghost Ships of the Great Lakes: Lost Beneath the Waves (Full Episode) | National Geographic
On this date in 1863, the schooner Rose Belle was launched
Looking back: schooner Rosa Belle's vanished crew
Columbine 25th Anniversary Memorial Edition
Elephant (2003 film) - Wikipedia (the movie by GusVan Sant, not Oliver Stone, Nic was trying to remember)

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians
“True North” by Bad Religion

All our episodes are at iwtrw.com (or at iwanttorewatch.com, if you want to type more letters for some reason).

Links for everything else I Want To Rewatch-related (including our sweet merch) are at the IWTRW Bio Site.

Recorded: 17 Aug 2025
Edited: 17 & 28 Aug 2025
Released: 29 August 2025

Links:
Leonid Kulik - Wikipedia
Tunguska event - Wikipedia
Meteoroid, Not Comet, Explains the 1908 Tunguska Fireball - Discover Magazine - 01 July 2013
Fire Came by: Riddle of the Great Siberian Explosion, 1908 (John Baxter and Thomas Atkins)
What Really Happened at Tunguska - Skeptoid #803
The Tunguska Event - TV Tropes
First-Hand Eyewitness Accounts May Shed New Light On The Tunguska Event
Tunguska: A Siberian Mystery and Its Environmental Legacy (Studies in Environment and History)
I Want to Rewatch - The X-Files - Season 4, Episode 8: “Tunguska”

While there does not seem to be a cocktail called “The Siberian Fireball” (c'mon, it's like y'all aren't even trying out there in bartenderland), we did come up with something for the adventurous... The “Siberian Fireball” Cocktail!

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

All our episodes are at iwtrw.com (or at iwanttorewatch.com, if you want to type more letters for some reason).

Links for everything else I Want To Rewatch-related (including our sweet merch) are at the IWTRW Bio Site.

Recorded: 26 July 2025
Edited: 14 Aug 2025
Released: 15 Aug 2025

Links:
Was frozen mammoth or giant ground sloth served for dinner at The Explorers Club? (Past) | Center for Genetic Analyses of Biodiversity
Revival of a ‘Frozen’ Dog--Some Cold New Disclosures (L.A. Times, July 6, 1987)
But What Will The Neighbors Think? A Discourse On The History And Rationale Of Neurosuspension - Cryonics Archive
In The Beginning: Vitrification or Freezing (PDF)
Inside TransTime Cryonics Facility: Bodies Frozen, Awaiting A Future Reawakening - CBS San Francisco (2019)
Luna Wilson - Cryonics Wiki
How Robert Anton Wilson's Daughter "Luna Wilson" became a cryogenically frozen brain in a vat
Screenshot_from_2024-01-06_15-02-03.png
I Want to Rewatch - In Search of... “Immortailty”

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

All our episodes are at iwtrw.com (or at iwanttorewatch.com, if you want to type more letters for some reason).

Links for everything else I Want To Rewatch-related (including our sweet merch) are at the IWTRW Bio Site.

Explore the mysteries of:

• The Bermuda Triangle
• The Bimini Road / Atlantis
• Robert the (Haunted) Doll
• The Coral Castle
• Monstera Deliciosa
• “Why did Nic do this?!”

Experience the horrors of:

• Travel (and Travel Anxiety)
• Jetlag
• Sunshine
• Open Water
• Social Anxiety
• Basically Everything!

Join us!

Recorded: 13 July 2025
Edited: 17 July 2025
Released: 18 July 2025

Note: The image used for this episode's cover art was (for the very first time) not created by hand, but by AI (via far too many prompts to get something usable, TBH).

(More) Links:
Skeptoid Adventure: Braving the Bermuda Triangle
How to Find Atlantis - Skeptoid Podcast #980
I Want to Rewatch - In Search of... “The Bermuda Triangle”
I Want to Rewatch - In Search of... “Atlantis”
The Upper Berth by F. Marion Crawford
Coral Castle - Skeptoid Podcast #149
Billy Idol - Sweet Sixteen (original MTV version)
Billy Idol - Sweet Sixteen (Official Version)
Mai-Kai Restaurant and Polynesian Show
Squaring the Strange - Episode 258: A ship of skeptics in the Bermuda Triangle!

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

All our episodes are at iwtrw.com (or at iwanttorewatch.com, if you want to type more letters for some reason).

Links for everything else I Want To Rewatch-related (including our sweet merch) are at the IWTRW Bio Site.

Recorded: 22 Mar 2025
Edited: 24-25 Mar 2025
Released: 02 May 2025

If your podcast feed isn't showing you a bunch of episode screenshots below this text, then head over to https://iwtrw.fireside.fm/iso-s03e04.

And, yes, Nic (perhaps fittingly) says idiosyncratic about a gazillion times in this episode when he should be saying ideomotor. Two and a half hours sleep, 40 ounces of cold brew espresso, and going off script will do that to you sometimes... Also, sometimes he's just dumb.

Links:
Vampires Ruined My Life
Dowsing - Wikipedia
Was King Arthur a Real Person? | Smithsonian
Francis Hitching - Wikipedia
In Search of... “The Magic of Stonehenge” - IWTRW
In Search of... “Haunted Castles” - IWTRW
Dowsing: a review - Anne Miller, Cambridge, England
Mind Mirror EEG - Original Mind Mirror
Mind Mirror EEG - Chapter 11: Experiences, anecdotes and testimonials offered by those who knew Max
Positive Health Online | Article - Dr Arthur Bailey Flower Essences
Dowsing for health : the applications and methods for holistic healing : Bailey, Arthur | Internet Archive
Anyone can dowse for better health : Bailey, Arthur | Internet Archive
Were Any Myths Deemed Too Simple to Test on MythBusters?
Doug Henning - Wikipedia

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

All our episodes are at iwtrw.com (or at iwanttorewatch.com, if you want to type more letters for some reason).

Links for everything else I Want To Rewatch-related (including our sweet merch) are at I Want To Rewatch | Linktree.

Recorded: 23 Feb 2025
Edited: 08 Mar 2025
Released: 04 Apr 2025

Links:
The ‘Dead Ringers’ Story: The Strange Death of the Twin Gynecologists
Clement Markert - Wikipedia
Tomax and Xamot - Wikipedia
Crimson Twins, Tomax and Xamot: G.I. Joe Compilation, Season 1+ Appearances
Dolly (sheep) - Wikipedia

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

All our episodes are at iwtrw.com (or at iwanttorewatch.com, if you want to type more letters for some reason).

Links for everything else I Want To Rewatch-related (including our sweet merch) are at I Want To Rewatch | Linktree.

Recorded: 23 Feb 2025
Edited: 07 Mar 2025
Released: 21 Mar 2025

Links:
The 1992 Campaign: Gaffes; Spelling by Quayle (That's With an E) - The New York Times
Tales From The Darkside - Opening Credits and Theme Song
Codell Kansas Tornadoes
1974 Super Outbreak - Wikipedia
2011 Super Outbreak - Wikipedia
National Severe Storms Laboratory - Wikipedia
Twister (soundtrack) - Wikipedia

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

All our episodes are at iwtrw.com (or at iwanttorewatch.com, if you want to type more letters for some reason).

Links for everything else I Want To Rewatch-related (including our sweet merch) are at I Want To Rewatch | Linktree.

Originally recorded: 19 June 2023
Originally edited: 26 June 2023
Originally released: 28 June 2023

Links:
⁠⁠Castle | Wikipedia⁠⁠ (first three sentences as a definition)
⁠⁠Wolfeton House: the 14th century home filled with tales of ghosts, royalty and rivalry | Bournemouth Echo⁠⁠
⁠⁠The wonders of Wolfeton | Dorset Echo⁠⁠ (literally the exact same article as above with a different title and different date)
⁠⁠Haunted Dorchester | Ghosts of Dorchester | Dorchester Ghosts | Dorchester Hauntings | Athelhampton House Ghosts | Old Malthouse Dorchester Ghosts | St Peters Church Dorchester Ghosts | Wolfeton House Ghosts⁠⁠ (at bottom)
⁠⁠Wolveton Gatehouse⁠⁠
⁠⁠Dorchester Ghosts, Folklore and Forteana⁠⁠ (Record 17 of 18)
⁠⁠Wolfeton House | Wikipedia⁠⁠
⁠⁠Bagley House⁠⁠
⁠⁠Merry England, (p. 263) | Google Books⁠⁠
Baglake v Bagley Explained?⁠⁠ (full text unavailable online)
⁠⁠Bettiscombe | Wikipedia⁠⁠
⁠⁠Screaming skull | Wikipedia⁠⁠
⁠⁠Sluggo’s House O’ Spookiness | The Screaming Skull of Bettiscombe Manor⁠⁠
⁠⁠The George | Google Street View ⁠⁠
⁠⁠In Search of... “The Loch Ness Monster” | I Want To Rewatch⁠⁠
⁠⁠In Search of... “The Magic of Stonehenge” | I Want To Rewatch⁠⁠

UPDATE: at 07:00 PDT on 28 June 2023, three hours after this episode originally posted, I received a reply regarding the Loch Ness clip on ⁠⁠⁠MonsterTalk⁠'⁠⁠s opening theme. It is from a preview for 1975's The Mysterious Monsters. That preview can be viewed on YouTube ⁠⁠⁠here⁠⁠⁠.

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

You can find links for basically everything I Want To Rewatch related (including our sweet merch) at:
I Want To Rewatch | Linktree

Originally recorded on 28 August 2022
Originally edited on 11 & 17 September 2022
Originally released on 21 September 2022
Previously re-released on 10 March 2023

References:
⁠Hans Holzer | Wikipedia⁠
⁠Hans Holzer at 100: America’s First TV Ghost Hunter | Den of Geek⁠
⁠Hans Holzer | Internet Archive⁠
⁠I Want To Rewatch | In Search of... “Strange Visitors⁠”
⁠Oh No Ross & Carrie and the Evidential Medium (Part 1)⁠ | ⁠(Part 2) ⁠
⁠Washington Irving’s Sunnyside | New York Haunted Houses⁠

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

You can find links for basically everything I Want To Rewatch related (including our sweet merch) at:
I Want To Rewatch | Linktree

Originally (not) recorded 07 January 2023
(LOST EPISODE) In Search of... “Astrology”

Recorded: 29 July 2023
Edited: 01 August 2023
Released: 30 August 2023

Corrections:
Nic said “Stan’s Bullpen” (0:16:51) when he, of course, meant “Stan’s Soapbox” but in the heat of the moment conflated that with “Bullpen Bulletins” and misspoke.
Nic also said “El Niña” (0:24:01), coupling a male article and female noun, which might sound sexy but is wrong. Sólo El Niño o La Niña hubieran sido correctos.

Links:
As above, so below | Wikipedia
Sydney Omarr | Wikipedia
Hans Eysenck | Wikipedia
Louis de Wohl | Wikipedia
Louis de Wohl: The Astrologer Who Helped Foil Hitler
George O. Abell | Wikipedia
John Nelson | Encyclopedia.com
Planetary Effects (scroll down a bit for John Henry Nelson)
Someone really didn't think this out at the JFK memorial | Imgur (this is actually from 2013, the 50th anniversary of JFK’s death, though still unknown if real)
Curse of Tippecanoe | Wikipedia (found after recording: a possible ‘answer’ to the lack of Presidential assassinations pre-1840 question)
Bullpen Bulletins | Wikipedia

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

You can find links for basically everything I Want To Rewatch related (including our sweet merch) at:
I Want To Rewatch | Linktree

Recorded: 29 July 2023
Edited: 01 August 2023
Released: 16 August 2023

Links:
Blizzard of 1977 | Wikipedia
Last Glacial Period | Wikipedia
Malthusianism | Wikipedia
Gifford H. Miller | Wikipedia
Scientists Suggest Global Warming Could Hasten the Next Ice Age | 21 January 1992
Cooling During Earth's Last Ice Age | 05 January 1997
Ancient Ice Yielding Secrets Of Climate | The New York Times | 09 August 1981
The History Of Early Polar Ice Cores (PDF)
James D. Hays | Wikipedia
(PDF) Variations in the Earth's Orbit: Pacemaker of the Ice Ages
(PDF) In Retrospect: Forty years of linking orbits to ice ages
Stephen Schneider (scientist) | Wikipedia
The Night New York’s Lights Went Out | American Experience | Official Site | PBS
Summer of 1976 (Europe) | Wikipedia
1976 British Isles heat wave | Wikipedia
Global cooling | Wikipedia
The Myth Of The 1970s Global Cooling Scientific Consensus | Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society | 01 September 2008
How the "Global Cooling" Story Came to Be | Scientific American | 10 January 2014
That ’70s myth—did climate science really call for a “coming ice age?” | Ars Technica

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

You can find links for basically everything I Want To Rewatch related (including our sweet merch) at:
I Want To Rewatch | Linktree

Recorded: 22 July 2023
Edited 31: July 2023
Released: 09 August 2023

If you missed it in the updated show notes for our “Haunted Castles” episode, here is the link for the preview of 1975's The Mysterious Monsters.  The Loch Ness bit is featured on ⁠⁠MonsterTalk⁠'⁠s opening theme, right after the clip of Leonard Nimoy from the In Search of “Bigfoot” episode.

Corrections:
Them! was released in 1954, not 1958.

Links:
Annual Report | Illinois Farmers’ Institute Dept. of Household Science (1897)
Rovi's North America's TV guides will go away! | alt.tv.tech.hdtv (2012)
View DICOM images? MicroDicom DICOM viewer! | PCbanter (2015)
SeaMonkey 2.49.1 (Windows) freezes (2017)
Solenopsis invicta | AntWiki
Fire ant | Wikipedia
Solenopsis invicta | antmaps.org
Formica (plastic) | Wikipedia
Nature's Miracle

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

You can find links for basically everything I Want To Rewatch related (including our sweet merch) at:
I Want To Rewatch | Linktree

Originally recorded: 19 June 2023
Originally edited: 26 June 2023
Originally released: 28 June 2023

Links:
⁠⁠Castle | Wikipedia⁠⁠ (first three sentences as a definition)
⁠⁠Wolfeton House: the 14th century home filled with tales of ghosts, royalty and rivalry | Bournemouth Echo⁠⁠
⁠⁠The wonders of Wolfeton | Dorset Echo⁠⁠ (literally the exact same article as above with a different title and different date)
⁠⁠Haunted Dorchester | Ghosts of Dorchester | Dorchester Ghosts | Dorchester Hauntings | Athelhampton House Ghosts | Old Malthouse Dorchester Ghosts | St Peters Church Dorchester Ghosts | Wolfeton House Ghosts⁠⁠ (at bottom)
⁠⁠Wolveton Gatehouse⁠⁠
⁠⁠Dorchester Ghosts, Folklore and Forteana⁠⁠ (Record 17 of 18)
⁠⁠Wolfeton House | Wikipedia⁠⁠
⁠⁠Bagley House⁠⁠
⁠⁠Merry England, (p. 263) | Google Books⁠⁠
Baglake v Bagley Explained?⁠⁠ (full text unavailable online)
⁠⁠Bettiscombe | Wikipedia⁠⁠
⁠⁠Screaming skull | Wikipedia⁠⁠
⁠⁠Sluggo’s House O’ Spookiness | The Screaming Skull of Bettiscombe Manor⁠⁠
⁠⁠The George | Google Street View ⁠⁠
⁠⁠In Search of... “The Loch Ness Monster” | I Want To Rewatch⁠⁠
⁠⁠In Search of... “The Magic of Stonehenge” | I Want To Rewatch⁠⁠

UPDATE: at 07:00 PDT on 28 June 2023, three hours after this episode posted, I received a reply regarding the Loch Ness clip on ⁠⁠⁠MonsterTalk⁠'⁠⁠s opening theme. It is from a preview for 1975's The Mysterious Monsters. That preview can be viewed on YouTube ⁠⁠⁠here⁠⁠⁠.

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

You can find links for basically everything I Want To Rewatch related (including our sweet merch) at:
I Want To Rewatch | Linktree

Originally recorded on 28 August 2022
Originally edited on 11 & 17 September 2022
Originally released on 21 September 2022

References:
⁠Hans Holzer | Wikipedia⁠
⁠Hans Holzer at 100: America’s First TV Ghost Hunter | Den of Geek⁠
⁠Hans Holzer | Internet Archive⁠
⁠I Want To Rewatch | In Search of... “Strange Visitors"⁠
⁠Oh No Ross & Carrie and the Evidential Medium (Part 1)⁠ | ⁠(Part 2) ⁠
⁠Washington Irving’s Sunnyside | New York Haunted Houses⁠

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

You can find links for basically everything I Want To Rewatch related (including our sweet merch) at:
I Want To Rewatch | Linktree

Originally recorded on 28 August 2022
Originally edited on 11 & 17 September 2022
Originally released on 21 September 2022

References:
⁠Hans Holzer | Wikipedia⁠
⁠Hans Holzer at 100: America’s First TV Ghost Hunter | Den of Geek⁠
⁠Hans Holzer | Internet Archive⁠
⁠I Want To Rewatch | In Search of... “Strange Visitors⁠”
⁠Oh No Ross & Carrie and the Evidential Medium (Part 1)⁠ | ⁠(Part 2) ⁠
⁠Washington Irving’s Sunnyside | New York Haunted Houses⁠

Music:
“Dark Science” by David Hilowitz
“The Truth Is What We Make of It” by The Agrarians

You can find links for basically everything I Want To Rewatch related (including our sweet merch) at:
I Want To Rewatch | Linktree